Logo
Lovejoy Surgicenter
ISSUE #33.28 • SCREEN • REVIEW

The Wind That Shakes The Barley


One of the year's best movies, full of passionate intensity.

Social bookmarking | Permalink
Email | Print | Rate It! | 0 comments
Recently in "Screen"

August 27th, 2008
When It’s Gray in L.A. | Midnight Kiss director explains the dark place where indie filmmaking meets Starbucks.0 comments

August 27th, 2008
Brew Views • Top 5 Movies to Watch in Theater Pubs This Week:0 comments

August 20th, 2008
Remotely Controlled • The 2008 Olympics | The Chinese have certainly learned marketing.2 comments

August 20th, 2008
A Fellow Of Infinite Jest | Some things are rotten in Hamlet 2, but not Steve Coogan.1 comment

August 13th, 2008
Tropic Thunder | Robert Downey Jr. has jungle fever.1 comment

August 13th, 2008
Halfway to a Threeway | Woody Allen’s European sex romp is a shocking triumph.1 comment

August 6th, 2008
Brew Views • Top 5 movies to watch in theater pubs this week0 comments

August 6th, 2008
My Winnipeg | Guy Maddin, now with more hockey.0 comments

August 6th, 2008
Pipe Dreams | David Gordon Green rolls some beauty into a Judd Apatow joint.0 comments

August 6th, 2008
American Teen | A documentary flunks high school.0 comments


BY N.P. THOMPSON | 503-243-2122

[May 23rd, 2007] The first unassailably great film of 2007, this account of small-town Irish lads circa 1920 who teach themselves the basics of guerrilla warfare—in order to rid their nation of rifle-toting Brits—has striking parallels to America's ongoing jingoist adventures in Iraq. But director Ken Loach and screenwriter Paul Laverty, who took home last year's Palme d'Or at Cannes, never force or emphasize political points in The Wind That Shakes the Barley. They concentrate at first on the brutality of British soldiers attacking unarmed Irish country folk; the inevitable backlash against the occupying army; and then the passionate disagreements over the uses of freedom, which in turn lead to still more bloodshed. The filmmakers show us the ease with which liberators can become oppressors.

As the earnest young men ensnared in this cycle, Cillian Murphy and Pádraic Delaney achieve a level of realism rarely attained in movies. The conflict between these two Catholic supporters of Irish sovereignty feels reminiscent of Martin Scorsese territory; it's a Scorsese film made by someone who can actually direct. With one graphic exception, Loach relies mainly on sound effects and quick cutaways to convey the carnage of war. (Barley also serves as strong medicine to counteract the sugarcoated, closure-obsessed banalities all too prevalent in The Lives of Others.)













icon Story continues below

advertisement
OMSI
advertisement

Loach, who 17 years ago made another film sympathetic to the IRA, the underrated thriller Hidden Agenda, understands there can be no "closure" in the wake of self-defeating compromises. The Irishmen in Barley live and die to establish a government of their own, yet when a Republican magistrate (an invigorating screen debut by a dark-haired actress named Fiona Lawton) rules against a weapons supplier, local followers of Sinn Féin conspire to overturn the verdict of her court. In the ensuing arguments, Laverty's script lays bare the fissures within the ranks. "Underneath, we're the same as the British," laments a survivor of the 1916 Easter Rising, and as you listen to the lacerating exchanges between people with common cause, you can see the wheels of civil war spinning. The single-minded pursuit of getting the British out of Ireland will be pushed to extremes, even if it entails (as it so often does) "the good guys" morphing into a version of their enemy.

It may be overreaching to claim that The Wind That Shakes the Barley resonates with the same heady intensity you get from reading Yeats, but I'll claim it; for a movie to be anywhere near that signifies a miracle of some sort.

Opens Friday, May 25, at Hollywood Theatre.

 

Rate This Story
4.67 average/3 votes

 
read all 0 comments | add your comment
 

RECENT COMMENTS ON “The Wind That Shakes The Barley”

 
 
 





Recently in Willamette Week
August 28th 2008Sometimes a Great Lawsuit | Ken Kesey’s last prank pits his widow in a court battle with his best friend and a Playboy model.
August 28th 2008Sliced Bread, Beware | A better fire hose, a poker aid & a foldable clipboard—meet six Portland inventors whose big ideas are the best thing since, well, you know.
August 28th 2008How to Live Cheap in Portland | Throwing too much money away on food and shelter? here’s WW’s Recession Survival Guide.
August 28th 2008The Queer and the Qur’an | Ali is gay. And Muslim. Can he be both?
August 28th 2008Good Cop, Mad Cop | Many of Navin Sharma’s colleagues in the Vancouver Police Department can’t believe he got fired. After reading this, neither will you.
August 28th 2008Lean, Mean Meat-Free Machine | Portlander Robert Cheeke is the face of vegan bodybuilding.
August 28th 2008The Sopranokovs | The Russian mob comes to town with a new scam—medical identity theft.
August 28th 2008Manhunter | Almost every state lets bounty hunters chase down its most wanted. Why doesn’t Oregon?
August 28th 2008Get Wet: WW’s Summer Guide 2008 | The rain is finally over. Now let’s get wet!