October 1st, 2008
Inbox0 comments
September 24th, 2008
Inbox0 comments
September 17th, 2008
Inbox2 comments
September 10th, 2008
Inbox1 comment
September 3rd, 2008
Inbox1 comment
August 27th, 2008
Inbox1 comment
August 20th, 2008
Inbox3 comments
August 13th, 2008
Inbox1 comment
August 6th, 2008
Inbox3 comments
[December 26th, 2007]
SURFACE DWELLER
After reading N.P. Thompson’s hissy fit masquerading as a review for The Savages (“Singing, Dancing, Dying,” WW , Dec. 19, 2007), I can only conclude that the writer spent his formative years sitting at the “cool kids” table making fun of everyone deemed beneath him. OK, we get it, Thompson doesn’t like Philip Seymour Hoffman and, to a lesser extent, Laura Linney. But to deride an Oscar-winning actor of Hoffman’s caliber as being merely “doughy cheek(ed)” and “multiple chin(ned)” is just mean-spirited. It’s also incredibly lazy writing.
The reviewer goes on to scorn Linney for “wearing a brown fright wig” and being involved with a character who is “homely” and (gasp) “sports a comb-over.” It makes one wonder why Thompson feels the need to spend so much of his precious few column inches on the physical shortcomings of the people in this film. Is his self-esteem really so low that making fun of the appearance of others is somehow self-elevating?
advertisement
If one just reads Thompson’s review, they might surmise that The Savages is a dud of a flick. The only problem with that is that the American Film Institute just named The Savages as one of the 10 most outstanding films of 2007. So, let’s see...do I trust the opinion of a respected panel of film experts, or the self-important ramblings of a frustrated hack with an obvious ax to grind?
David Benedetti
North Concord Avenue
RECENT COMMENTS ON “Inbox”
Dear NP,
Thank you for responding, I think I owe a clarification. I, like most people I think, do not look for talent, originality, wit or insight in a movie review. I (we) look for...
Naz,
Since I'm the guy who brought N. P. into the WW fold, and have no intention of tossing him back out again, I'll offer my two cents. Dependability is a crucial quality in a crit...
Aaron,
You are correct; you do come across as a bit condescending. But I shall follow your lead and attempt to be a kind online person too.
I don't care whether m...
NP & Aaron
If Oscars can be won on reputation, then I imagine being asked to vote in the Village Voice/LA Weekly poll can be a bit of an insiders good old boy selection as well. Bu...








