Logo
Lovejoy Surgicenter
ISSUE #34.09 • CULTURE • COLUMN
Hot Seat

Laura Ireland Moore


A local animal-law activist on medical research, having a pet and whether the Inuit should be allowed to hunt.

Social bookmarking | Permalink
Email | Print | Rate It! | 30 comments
Recently in "Hot Seat"

August 20th, 2008
Craig Allen | Home Depot employee wins gold medal…for philosophy.0 comments

August 13th, 2008
Thomas Frank | The left’s brain on what’s the matter with Obama.2 comments

August 6th, 2008
Julius Achon | A Portland runner’s Olympian survival story.1 comment

July 30th, 2008
Dylan Goldsmith | The one-man operation Captured By Porches isn’t a microbrewery, it’s a nanobrewery.5 comments

July 16th, 2008
LaJean Lawson | She follows the bouncing breast.4 comments

July 9th, 2008
Darrel Lee | Portland pastor builds near-term empire, fears long-term locusts.3 comments

June 11th, 2008
Steven Wax | Reading this may result in warrantless wiretapping.0 comments

June 4th, 2008
Richard Preston | The Hot Zone author talks Ebola, self-cannibals and getting into the soup.1 comment

May 21st, 2008
Abrahm Lustgarten | Riding the rails to Tibet on the eve of the Beijing Olympics.5 comments

April 30th, 2008
Alice Feiring | Why wine geeks need to tell Robert Parker to cork it.0 comments


Learn More: Lewis&Clark will host its 16th annual animal-law conference in October. For more information, see lclark.edu/org/ncal.
BY JEREMY GILLICK | jgillick at wweek dot com

[January 9th, 2008]

Laura Ireland Moore has been fighting for animals ever since she founded an animal rights group while attending junior high in La Grange, Ill.

A vegan by age 16, Moore got her degree in environmental studies from the University of Colorado. In 1998 she enrolled at Lewis&Clark Law School, where animal law was growing in popularity among students. After graduating in 2001, she founded the National Center for Animal Law at Lewis&Clark, a division of the law school.

Still only 31, Moore directs the center and teaches 15 to 20 students a year. The center rarely embroils itself in public disputes, but Moore recently became involved in one when she wrote Dean Mark Richardson of Oregon Health&Science University last month to urge him to “discontinue the use of live pigs” in a first-year elective course. Moore is leaving her job in August because her husband is taking a job elsewhere. But we asked her in the meantime to explain more about the developing field of animal law.

WW: What differentiates your center from other animal rights groups?
Laura Ireland Moore: I wouldn’t say we’re an animal rights group. We do animal protection law. We only take cases and work on issues when it’s furthering the interests of animals. There are other animal-law attorneys who do not necessarily work for animals. Environmental law is a good parallel. There are environmental lawyers protecting the trees and there are environmental lawyers protecting the companies who cut down the trees. Animal law is the same sort of thing.

Should animals have rights like humans, or is it that humans should have more responsibilities toward animals?
It’s certainly not that animals should have the right to vote or to have a car. It’s about respecting what each individual species needs. Under the current laws, some animals do have protection from cruelty—those are companion animals. But the law is set up to exempt things that are cruel to animals, basically if we make money off them. If you look at the Oregon anti-cruelty statute, it exempts rodeos, common husbandry practices, any sort of research.

While hunting may seem cruel in America, because it’s not necessary for most people’s survival, what happens in a culture where people must hunt to survive? Do animals still have the same rights?
Animals are not on this planet for us to use. There needs to be respect for the fact that they are individual living beings. If people can live without using animals, they should do that.

What about the Inuit in Canada, who help support themselves by hunting?
I’m not an expert on the Inuit. But if they can mine and sell gas, diamonds, gold and heavy metals, they can certainly ship in some tofu. If everyone had as much respect for animals and the sacrifice they make for humans as [they do] for native cultures, this world would be a much better place.

You also oppose using animals for research?
Yes. I’m not a doctor, I’m not a researcher. But there’s a lot of research from the medical community that shows animal testing doesn’t work. We don’t have a cure for cancer, we don’t have a cure for AIDS. Knowing how something works in a rat doesn’t tell you how it works in a person, because our bodies are different.



















icon Story continues below

advertisement

advertisement

What if there were cases where it actually did benefit humans?
Well, but it’s a hypothetical that’s not true, so…

But—
I’m not going to answer that question.

OHSU spokesman Jim Newman has a list of some medical advances made possible by animal testing. They include the smallpox vaccine (cows), the polio vaccine (monkeys) and insulin.
Jim and others in the animal research industry have personal and financial interests in perpetuating the myth that animal research works.

Have you ever had a pet?
We have two dogs and two cats. They have really good lives. They own us; we don’t own them.

It seems strange you would think having pets is OK.
There’s debate about that. But most people in the animal advocacy movement do not have a problem with people having pets, or, as we call them, companion animals. Legally, animals are property. But they’re living beings as well. What we do have a problem with is puppy mills and pet stores and the fact that people buy and sell animals.

Where’d you get your pets?
The two cats were from friends who lived next door to a man whose cat lived outdoors and wasn’t spayed. They watched her get pregnant a number of times and her kittens would become feral. The neighbor finally allowed my friends to get her spayed—they took the pregnant cat in, took care of her kittens, got everyone spayed and neutered and I have two of those cats. One of our dogs was adopted from the humane society. Our other dog was rescued from a reservation in Washington.

Why oppose the use of live pigs in a class at OHSU?
That’s not something we normally do. We were contacted by concerned OHSU students. I didn’t know it was gonna go to the press. I was just writing a letter to say, “Hey, this isn’t OK.” We don’t really take positions on a lot of things. The Animal Welfare Act requires you to use non-animal alternatives when they are available. So our position was: The Animal Welfare Act requires you to stop this. Since 126 other schools educate their medical students without using live animals, it seems like there’s a reasonable alternative.

OHSU’s Newman says many of those schools actually do use live pigs for this class, but because they are private schools, they are not subject to the same level of scrutiny as schools like OHSU.
Whether it’s 60 or 120 schools, there’s a way to have medical students become good doctors without using live animals in the classroom.

Do you go to the zoo?
I loved the zoo when I was little. But I haven’t been in decades.

What do you make of the tiger attack in San Francisco several weeks ago?
In one sense, you get exposed to animals by seeing them. But, as we’ve seen, having wild animals in captivity is not good. It’s dangerous for people and there’s just not a way to do it humanely. Animals should be in the wild.











Fact: Over 120 illegal acts were committed by animal rights groups in America in 2006—the most ever in a year, according to Science magazine. About two-thirds—66 percent—of the targets were biomedical in nature.

 

Rate This Story
1.48 average/50 votes

 
read all 30 comments | add your comment
 

RECENT COMMENTS ON “Laura Ireland Moore”

23

air isn't for us to use, people need to respect air is individual molecules, if people can live without using air, they should do that

I has teeth, Jan 13th, 2008 12:46pm
24

Hey Luv,

Thanks for those links. If you read what I wrote you'd actually know that I understand what factory farms do to the land. But I also know that agriculture is what created t...

Urban Scout, Jan 13th, 2008 7:25pm
25

If you think she is forcing her views on others, what do you think you are doing when you kill animals for your taste buds? You flesh-eaters force your views upon your victims in one of the worst ways...

Melissa, Jan 16th, 2008 12:03pm
26

I really wish 'evolutionary biologist' had elaborated more... The main point that is begging to be made would really benefit from her/his expertise, but I will try my best.

In the...

what peaches and what, Jan 24th, 2008 10:15am
 
 
 





Recently in Willamette Week
August 20th 2008Sliced Bread, Beware | A better fire hose, a poker aid & a foldable clipboard—meet six Portland inventors whose big ideas are the best thing since, well, you know.
August 20th 2008How to Live Cheap in Portland | Throwing too much money away on food and shelter? here’s WW’s Recession Survival Guide.
August 20th 2008The Queer and the Qur’an | Ali is gay. And Muslim. Can he be both?
August 20th 2008Good Cop, Mad Cop | Many of Navin Sharma’s colleagues in the Vancouver Police Department can’t believe he got fired. After reading this, neither will you.
August 20th 2008Lean, Mean Meat-Free Machine | Portlander Robert Cheeke is the face of vegan bodybuilding.
August 20th 2008The Sopranokovs | The Russian mob comes to town with a new scam—medical identity theft.
August 20th 2008Manhunter | Almost every state lets bounty hunters chase down its most wanted. Why doesn’t Oregon?
August 20th 2008Get Wet: WW’s Summer Guide 2008 | The rain is finally over. Now let’s get wet!
August 20th 2008New Kids In The Flock | Gresham’s twin teenage sensations go about their Father’s business. And it’s making them superstars.