Logo
ISSUE #34.13 • NEWS • NEWS STORY
[COURTS]

The Debt Effect


One of Oregon’s biggest collection lawyers faces new troubles from the debtors he’s sued.

Recently in "News"

July 1st, 2009
Q & A • John Kroger | Oregon’s Attorney General Answers WW’s Questions on The Adams Report.10 comments

July 1st, 2009
Cover Story • The Good, The Bad And The Awful | WW’s biennial ranking of metro-area legislators.45 comments

July 1st, 2009
Hey, Neighbor! • Hey, Neighbor!0 comments

July 1st, 2009
Double Standards | John Kroger’s report on the mayor comes under fire from ex-prosecutor and victims’ advocate.3 comments

July 1st, 2009
Murmurs • Don’t Stop ’Til You Get Enough.3 comments

July 1st, 2009
Strip Fees | A dancer sues her ex-boss in an industry where many strippers don’t make wages.3 comments

July 1st, 2009
Letters to the Editor • Inbox | But Wait—There’s More!0 comments

July 1st, 2009
Ask the Editor • What Were We Thinking? | WW Editor Mark Zusman answers your questions about our coverage.5 comments

June 24th, 2009
Cover Story • The Adams Report | Fourteen fascinating things we learned from Attorney General John Kroger’s investigation.57 comments

June 24th, 2009
Hey, Neighbor! • Hey, Neighbor!0 comments



IMAGE: Eben Dickinson
BY JAMES PITKIN | jpitkin at wweek dot com

[February 6th, 2008]

One of the state’s top debt-collection lawyers now finds himself targeted by the Oregon State Bar and the people he sued, who claim he broke the law or used shady legal tactics in his effort to collect debts of thousands of dollars.

Derrick McGavic, a 69-year-old Eugene lawyer, may have his license yanked by the bar for violating professional standards. On a separate front, McGavic faces a pair of new federal lawsuits alleging he ran afoul of the 1978 Fair Debt Collection Practices Act by trying to squeeze debtors.

McGavic has already settled a string of six federal lawsuits in the past two years over his collection tactics, which allegedly included threatening defendants with jail time, hiring professional snoops to obtain personal information, and suing people who didn’t actually owe money.

McGavic declined to comment on the bar complaint or the amount of the settlements, but said his office would never knowingly violate the rules. “Suffice it to say, you get more flies with honey than you do with vinegar,” he says.

As the economy slouches toward recession and the average U.S. household’s credit-card debt tops $8,700, more Portlanders are finding themselves in the crosshairs of debt-collection lawyers like McGavic.

“The screws are really getting tightened,” says Keith Karnes, a Portland consumer lawyer who’s represented clients in suits against McGavic and other debt-collection lawyers. “I’m busier than I should be.”

After 45 years in business, McGavic has built one of the most successful debt-collection practices in the state, filing thousands of lawsuits each year, according to his competitors. Most of his work is in southern Oregon, but he also leaves a footprint in Portland—on one day alone last month, he filed 26 lawsuits in Multnomah County Circuit Court.

To understand why a lawyer might cross the line in his efforts to collect, it helps to know a bit about how America’s billion-dollar debt-collection industry works.

Credit-card companies sell their uncollected debts to debt-purchasing companies, who buy them by the thousands for up to 20 cents on the dollar. Many of those debts are past time to collect. Others have been discharged under bankruptcy. But if the companies play hardball, they can collect enough to turn a profit.

So they hire collection agencies and lawyers like McGavic, who can win a court order to raid bank accounts and garnish wages to pay off the debt. But there’s risk for the lawyers as well. They get paid only 25 to 30 percent of what they collect—if they turn up nothing, there’s no paycheck.

The lawyers file dozens of boilerplate lawsuits at a time, hoping a few pan out. Some debtors won’t respond at all. Then the lawyer wins a default judgment and the right to collect—though the deadbeats, if they can be located, often have nothing left to take.















icon Story continues below

advertisement

advertisement

Portland debt lawyer David Schumacher says the work is typically a lawyer’s last resort. “It’s the necessary evil,” he says. “If you do it right, you’ll be successful at it. I’m just amazed at the rules that are broken out there. It just blows me away.”

McGavic has racked up 35 bar complaints in the last 10 years, as far back as records are available. The bar found enough evidence on one of those to prosecute and on Jan. 3 filed a formal complaint against McGavic in Oregon Supreme Court.

The complaint alleges McGavic continued to contact a debtor after she referred all correspondence to her attorney, a breach of legal ethics. McGavic could face suspension or disbarment if the court rules against him.

McGavic also faces two federal lawsuits filed Jan. 11 at U.S. District Court in Portland. Both claim McGavic sent a document to debtors saying he could have them thrown in jail if they didn’t let him contact their employers.

“A lot of creditors call people’s work to harass and embarrass them,” says Karnes, the lawyer who filed both lawsuits. “McGavic tries to get permission to do that, and it’s illegal under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.”

Karnes says McGavic has paid to settle four other lawsuits brought by Karnes’ clients alleging McGavic made the same threat. McGavic has since added the word “optional” in the document he sends to debtors, but it’s still questionable whether it’s legal, Karnes says.

“Threatening anybody with jail is very risky and something that is very unusual,” says Portland debt-collection lawyer Brian Sullivan. “I certainly would never do that.”

Karnes says McGavic has settled two other suits he filed. One alleged McGavic sued the wrong debtor. Another accused McGavic of hiring an agent who lied to obtain personal information about a debtor over the phone.

McGavic isn’t the only prominent statewide debt-collection lawyer from Eugene facing a federal lawsuit. Another, Daniel Gordon, was sued Jan. 31 for pursuing a debt after the statute of limitations expired.

Gordon did not respond to requests for comment on the suit against him, but he defends his friend McGavic. “I would say he’s a very careful guy,” Gordon says. “In fact, sometimes I think he’s overkill on careful.”

FACT: If a lawyer or collection agency is after you for a debt, experts say your best defense is to ask for details on the debt, including who you owe, the date of the debt, added costs and documentation. Often, the debt-buying company doesn’t have that information and will drop the case.

 

Rate This Story
4.9 average/30 votes

 
read all 48 comments | add your comment
 

RECENT COMMENTS ON “The Debt Effect”

45

RE:Derrick E. Mc Gavic and his robotic cronies. I'm more than willing to repay old debts but after doing so they ignore your payments and garnish you anyway. So, why am I paying at all?After having re...

Dave, Dec 1st, 2008 4:41pm
46

Derrick McGavic garnihed my Soc. Security and my reverse mortgage chec.

His office or would not talk to me as the "The debt was not mine"

I am 73 and t...

sharon, Feb 14th, 2009 7:31pm
47

ATTENTION PEOPLE CLASS ACTION AGAINST DANIEL GORDON CONTACT SPOKANE ATTORNEY

MICHAEL D KINKLEY 4407 N. DIVISION SUITE

914 SPOKANE WASHINGTON 509-484-5611

Sherry, May 10th, 2009 12:20am
48

an attorney friend of mine told me that becoming a debt collector attorney is what happens when you graduate at the bottom of your law school class.

k, May 10th, 2009 8:31am
 
 
 





Recently in Willamette Week
December 31st 1969Washington State | The Canada of Oregon has it all—a Stonehenge replica, a longboarder's concrete wet dream and dark, damp underground lava caves. Vive les rocks.
December 31st 1969Oregon's Outer Edges | Crater Lake. Hell's Canyon. Wallowa and Steens mountain ranges. Hell, yeah.
December 31st 1969Central Oregon/High Desert | No rain, plenty of snow, obsidian flows and great local beer. The folks from the real eastside know how to unbend outside.
December 31st 1969Great Cascades/Columbia Gorge | With plenty of room to roam—and hot springs for your weary feet—it's the place to ramble and relax for the weekend.
December 31st 1969Willamette Valley | Monks, tracks, tubing and wine make the fertile strip a virile place to play.
December 31st 1969Stumptown | Tons of public parks, an extinct volcano and nude beach volleyball to keep you jolly. Get out and collect those merit badges, without leaving the city.
December 31st 1969The Coast | The beaches are public. You own them. Go play—hike in the old-growth forests.
December 31st 1969Cycle Tour 101: Your on-bike guide to Highway 101 | To ride the greatest bike route in Oregon, you need to get out of Portland.
December 31st 1969Doggin' It | What happens when a Portland running club jogs with pooches from the pound?
December 31st 1969Over the Edge | Sam Drevo will paddle yr ass.