Logo
Aequis
ISSUE #34.13 • NEWS • NEWS STORY
[ENVIRONMENT]

Boom With A View


Economics vs. Environment in the Gorge.

Social bookmarking | Permalink
Email | Print | Rate It! | 1 comment
Recently in "News"

May 7th, 2008
Cover Story • Best New Band 2008 | Portland music insiders take our local scene to the chopping block—and come out with 10 new faves. 0 comments

May 7th, 2008
Holy Smoke | High times for marijuana marchers.9 comments

May 7th, 2008
Trib Translation | An annotation of last week’s news about the news.9 comments

May 7th, 2008
Murmurs • Where We Gather Each Week To See How We Live.4 comments

May 7th, 2008
Rogue of the Week • Elaine Franklin | Thy name is mud-slinging.1 comment

May 7th, 2008
Honor Thy Neighbor | But covet your own U.S. Senate candidate.0 comments

May 7th, 2008
Quick Picks for the Primary | A WW endorsements cheat sheet for your vote-by-mail ballot.2 comments

May 7th, 2008
Pop Quiz • What do you see in the picture? | WW’s weekly election feature—designed to scare the hell out of City Hall candidates.0 comments

May 7th, 2008
Getting In Gear | Can 5,000 cyclists swing a City Hall election?0 comments

May 7th, 2008
The Big Dump | A Sauvie Island resident’s fight to prevent an isle of blight.3 comments


Gouge in the Gorge: A rendering of what one stretch of the Columbia Gorge could look like.
IMAGE: broughtonlanding.com
BY JEREMY GILLICK | jgillick at wweek dot com

[February 6th, 2008]

The Columbia River Gorge Commission is deliberating whether to let a lumber company build a 250-unit resort in violation of existing rules against a large-scale development. And Gorge defenders are crying foul.

“The level of political pressure is particularly unusual,” says Michael Lang, a spokesman for Friends of the Columbia Gorge. “[Congressman] Brian Baird [D-Wash.] is really pushing this.”

Congress and then-President Ronald Reagan created the Gorge Commission by passing the National Scenic Area Act in 1986. The Act gave the commission two tasks: to protect the Gorge and to promote its development.

Now those two tasks are in conflict as struggling timber companies must find new uses for their land and Skamania County, Wash., needs to boost its sluggish economy.

` On Jan. 10, Jill Arens, the commission’s executive director, sided with the economic development mandate. She recommended the 13-member commission approve an amendment allowing Broughton Lumber Company to build a resort on a 50-acre inactive mill site it owns on the Washington side of the Gorge. The commission will hold its last public hearing on the matter at the Hood River Best Western Inn at 9 am Feb. 12, and will reach a final decision in March.

Arens calls the issue “very complicated” and says she sided with Broughton because it offered “a reasonable solution that will help the gorge overall.”

Nonetheless, the timing of a letter sent Oct. 4 by Baird and U.S. Sen. Patty Murray (D-Wash.) encouraging the commission to accept Broughton’s development offer raises questions with Friends of the Columbia Gorge and others.

Last Sept. 17 and 20, Baird received $11,000 in contributions from executives with Broughton and SDS Lumber—two Bingen, Wash., companies that share owners and top executives.

Pat Meeks, a Klickitat County Democrat, researched the contribution histories of SDS owner Wally Stevenson as well as SDS president—and Broughton general manager—Jason Spadaro. Meeks, who opposes the development, says she was “extremely surprised” to discover “that a company that has always supported such conservative candidates would suddenly give to a liberal Democrat.”















icon Story continues below

advertisement

advertisement

“This isn’t the first time I’ve contributed to a Democratic campaign, nor will it be the last,” Spadaro says. “I support individuals based on the policies they vote for, not their party affiliations.”

Baird’s letter sounded the alarm for Lang and Meeks because they say Baird has a good record otherwise on Gorge issues. Baird, however, says his support for the Broughton Landing Resort is genuine and that it “vastly predates the contributions.”

“Here’s an opportunity to take an eyesore and turn it into something useful,” Baird says.

U.S. Rep. Earl Blumenauer (D-Ore) differs from his fellow Democrat. “While I have no objection to appropriate economic development in the Gorge,” Blumenauer wrote to the commission on Jan. 25, “this proposal appears to me on an unnecessarily large scale and in conflict with the provisions of the act.”

While there’s little doubt that Baird wants to create the 288 temporary and 60 permanent jobs Broughton Lumber claims the project will create, Lang says economic growth is possible without the amendment.

Lang supports the development of a “rustic resort” that includes cabins and camping on the site. Broughton, Lang believes, intends to build a housing project with “no assurance the public would have access.”

Says Arens: “I don’t like to predict, but it may well be that we’ll end up in court.”

FACTS: Stevenson and Spadaro have given upward of $40,000 to Republican candidates and causes over the past 20 years. Spadaro has never before given to a Democrat; the last Democrat to receive Stevenson’s support was then U.S. Rep. Les AuCoin (D-Ore.), who received $1,000 in 1992.

 

Rate This Story
4.43 average/7 votes

Comment on this article

Bust  writes on Feb 8th, 2008 11:00pm

And now for the rest of the self-executing template:

1. Spineless Dem from outside of PDX sells out to developer

2. Envirolitigators begin to circle and use land use laws to enforce their version of morality and proper development, as distinct from that of greedy developer

3. PDX politicians milk controversy

4. Media milks controversy

5. Government agency whores itself to developer and approves project

6. Court makes conservative decision siding with envirolitigators concept of moral and proper development to stop project and awards fees to happy envirolitigators

7. Land use law recognized as unsustainable, selectively enforced, meaningless vehicle for political decisionmaking under the color of law that it is

8. Developer issues standard gripe about anti development attitudes

9. Spineless Dem makes off with campaign cash

10. Hippies blather about how area "saved" was "sacred"

10. Rinse, lather, repeat ad nauseum. Form new shell group for envirolitigation if necessary. See e.g., Cooper Spur.

Comment on the "Boom With A View" article



Ad
Charles Lewis

Ad
Little Dog Laughed
Ad

Sponsored Links: WW Personals
Musician's Market
Snowboard Jackets


Recently in Willamette Week
May 10th 2008Best New Band 2008 | Portland music insiders take our local scene to the chopping block—and come out with 10 new faves.
May 10th 2008For The Love of Politics | WW’s endorsement page-turner has all the candidates worth falling for this election.
May 10th 2008Say Amen, Somebody | African-American ministers struggle to make their voices heard in America’s whitest city.
May 10th 2008Green With Envy | Seven things Portland should do if we’re serious about being green.
May 10th 2008Kvetch Fest | 27 things we hate about the city we love.
May 10th 2008Bitter Pill | A Portland doc flips on big pharma and reveals its “dirty little secret.”
May 10th 2008Gunfight at the OR Corral | A crusader who fought the Mob or a long-established Oregonian? Inside the shootout to become the next attorney general.
May 10th 2008Lean Cuisine | Has Portland lost its insatiable appetite for its restaurant scene?
May 10th 2008Barack In The Day | Long before Obama ran for president, he was a state senator in Illinois. Here’s what he did.
May 10th 2008The Adventures of Zetaman | Portland’s superhero bunks in the ’burbs and drives a minivan—when he’s not keeping our streets safe.