|

WW
welcomes
letters to the editor via mail, e-mail
or fax. Letters must be signed by the author and include
the author's street address and phone number for verification.
Preference will be given to letters of 250 words or less.
SLOW DAY AT THE MOULIN ROGUE
It must have been a quiet week for the Roguemeister, forced
to resurrect one of last year's most ill-chosen Rogues and
try to dress it in new school-year togs [Rogue of the Week,
WW, Sept. 27, 2000].
The Portland French School. Puh-LEEZE.
First off, "alert newshounds" with a taste for accuracy
will recall that in 1998 the school erected a fence around
a small paved portion of the schoolyard, not a "fence and
hedge" around its fields and playground, as the Roguemeister
contends. The main "greenspace" on the property, between
the school and Corbett Avenue, remained open then and is
open today. A little fact-checking, peut-être?
As for Marc Abrams' bluff talk and tough stance (which
belies his own more effete private-university credentials),
he has grandstanded this issue for more than a year now
and, while his faux-populism may play well with certain
school board constituencies, must take responsibility for
fanning the flames of a neighborhood dispute that has always
been a tempest in a teapot.
The Portland French School is leasing the Terwilliger School
from the school district and paying a market rate which
is presumably welcome revenue from a property that had gone
under-utilized for years. The school survived an unpleasant,
at times painful, conflict with the neighborhood association
during the land-use process. It has now added color, culture,
activity and the joy of young children to a corner of the
Corbett neighborhood where that use fits.
The school doesn't deserve more cheap shots. In fact, a
little fraternité would be nice for a change.
Edward C. Wolf
Northeast 18th Avenue
WHEN CARTOONISTS DREAM
Oh, that Callahan! What a crackup! He thinks the Portland
School Board is really doing a terrible disservice to this
country by not allowing armed-forces recruitment on school
campuses [Callahan, Sept. 20, 2000]. Perhaps it has
been much too long since he was 18, because I was this age
myself just six years ago, and every branch of the
military called my home number at least four times, despite
my near-complete lack of interest.
Reviewing Mr. Callahan's book He Won't Get Far on Foot,
I did not notice anything about him doing a stint in the
military--it seems that, before his injury, he spent much
of his time drinking. Of course this is a prerequisite for
the military, but it does not make one a soldier. I did
the same thing for many years, and earned no medals.
I believe it was on Sept. 17 that there was an article
in The Oregonian about U.S. troops in Kosovo, detailing
how they sometimes murder the people they were sent to protect,
and another tale of an officer (a sergeant) raping and murdering
a young girl. Is this the illustrious, respectable military
career Callahan feels he missed out on, and needs to make
sure no one else is deprived of such opportunity for absolute
terror? When I saw him at the Phil Lesh/Bob Dylan show this
summer, was he giving out Army pamphlets?
Well, if one has dreams of being a government-sanctioned
drug trafficker, there's always
the Navy.
José Carter
North Missouri Avenue
WHO YOU CALLIN' YUPPIE?
Two years ago I bought a house in North Overlook, one of
the hot gentrification areas you designated in your article
of Sept. 20 ["The Face of Gentrification"]. We bought in
this neighborhood primarily because we were priced out of
the market in other areas of the city. In researching the
area before I moved in, the demographic picture showed a
neighborhood that was mixed but has never had a large minority
population--it was an old Polish, working class area--and
most of the established residents are elderly, who have
been here since the 1940s and 1950s.
That picture is changing rapidly as new, younger, perhaps
more educated people move in, but certainly gay people,
Hispanics and African-Americans are also moving into the
neighborhood (and are probably just as well-educated or
as professional as the straight whites who are here.) Affluent,
educated whites are not the only people moving here, and
minorities are not being forced out. I have Hispanic neighbors,
and there are a number of newer black families throughout
the neighborhood. I bought my home on a zero-down, V.A.
loan--hardly the sign of affluence. The people I know who
moved here did so for the same reasons we did--the area
is relatively diverse, they couldn't afford anything else,
the housing is well-maintained and the crime-rates are low.
This so-called 'gentrification' you were trying to prove
with your statistics simply is not a reality in this neighborhood.
Gary Lorentzen
North Sumner Street
Chris Lydgate responds: According to the study
cited in the article, the area of Overlook where Mr. Lorentzen
lives is experiencing rising household income, an influx
of professionals and college grads, rising property values,
higher rent, higher residential mobility and an increase
in affluent white homebuyers compared with Multnomah County
as a whole.
That doesn't mean that all the new inhabitants of Overlook
are yuppies, nor does it mean they are all white, nor does
it mean they are all straight. It just means that there
is solid evidence that Overlook (along with several other
North Portland neighborhoods)
is gentrifying.
While I admire Mr. Lorentzen's casual dismissal of statistics
as a basis for measuring social change, I worry about the
consequences: packs of unemployed statisticians roaming
the streets in search of stray percentage points, while
policymakers make decisions based on the entrails of sheep.
MEET THE NEIGHBORS
I read the "Alberta Rising?" article [WW, Sept.
6] on the way to my neighborhood association meeting and
finished it fuming and disappointed. Mr. Dawdy could have
benefited from attending the meeting himself and talking
to residents--African-American women who have lived in the
neighborhood since the '50s, white 20-somethings like my
husband and myself, a middle-aged lesbian couple. We reviewed
architectural plans for low-income plexes to be built across
the street from my house and discussed the concerns of the
neighborhood.
People moving here are doing so because Alberta is one
of the last truly diverse areas in Portland and one in which
houses are still affordable. Many residents are committed
to maintaining diversity and not running anyone out of their
houses or any of the low-income options in abundance here
(which you neglected to discuss). No one on our block complained
when we bought and starting fixing up what had been a crack
house with a lawn full
of garbage.
It's the hip thing to do to complain about gentrification.
But it is more responsible to give a fair picture of the
issue. If you'd contacted the local neighborhood associations
or talked to a full range of residents, you would have come
away with a much different story. The issue of gentrification
and displacement is a valid one to raise, but those of us
who are working to keep the Alberta neighborhood a diverse
and safe place to live deserve a say as well.
Brittney Corrigan-McElroy
Northeast 10th Avenue
NOT JUST SPECULATION
As manager of the Bureau of Housing and Community Development's
contract with Sabin CDC to undertake revitalization efforts
on Alberta since 1995, I valued much of Philip Dawdy's article
["Alberta Rising?," WW, Sept. 6, 2000]. Efforts that
publicize the
dangers of displacement are always valuable.
However, I was upset by what I saw as simplistic characterizations
of Rosyln Hill and Eric Wentland as speculators. In the
revitalization of neighborhoods that experience disinvestment,
you need courageous developers and merchants to stem that
tide, to put vacant neglected buildings into productive
use. Alberta thankfully had a handful, Roslyn and Eric among
them. Additionally, Alberta has a core of unsung volunteers
who've labored on complementary activities that build community:
youth projects designing street banners, trash cans and
presenting the street's history; clean-up and anti-litter
campaigns; graffiti removal on others' buildings; mentoring
others on permit processes and the storefront improvement
program; innumerable meetings on the street fair and streetscape
design; establishing a merchants association to be responsible
for projects begun under Sabin now that our funding has
concluded. Roslyn and Eric have supported or led these efforts.
Yes, personality disagreements exist. Yes, there are tensions
with the success of Alberta's revitalization, and we should
all be concerned with the displacement of long-term African-American
residents. But to suggest that those who've invested when
Alberta was still a battleground are "itching to make good
on their bets" is inaccurate. My experience tells me they
are passionate about maintaining Alberta's multicultural
diversity, and committed to the community for the long-term.
Howard Cutler
Bureau of Housing and Community Development
City
of Portland
|