
Seen
a Rogue on the loose?
Get in touch with our Roguemeister:
JOHN SCHRAG
jschrag@wweek.com
(503) 243-2122
FAX:
(503) 243-1115
Once you get beyond the playground taunts, the field of
eyeware might seem a pretty safe career. But optical office
politics can get rough, as optometrist Trevor Hay learned
last month when his former employer, Reynolds Optical,
dropped into the realm of Roguery.
On the evening of March 6, Hay used his key to unlock the
door to Reynolds Optical's downtown branch, where he kept
an office, to check on the next day's appointments. He looked
in his appointment book and found that a line had been drawn
next to each appointment, and next to each was scrawled
the word "CANCELLED."
Then, outside his office, he found his 1,050 patients'
files had been placed in boxes.
That, Hay says, is when he realized he was being kicked
out.
There had been friction between Hays and Reynolds for months.
Just a week or two before, he'd met with another optical
store about relocating. Clearly, word had gotten back to
Reynolds.
But Hay says he didn't appreciate the degree of acrimony
until he opened up his patients' file folders. His patients'
medical histories were gone--and with them, Hay's only record
of their address and phone number.
The aggrieved optometrist sued Reynolds last month, claiming
a half-million in damages to his business.
Officials from Reynolds did not return WW's calls.
However, in court documents, the store has taken the position
that it considered Hay a quasi-employee and the medical
histories proprietary information.
Still, it seems odd that the store shredded the records,
as it has admitted in court documents. "I have never had
anything that malicious happen to me before," Hay says.
Hay isn't the only one seeing red over the episode. His
suit includes an affidavit by David Plunkett, the executive
director for the Oregon Board of Optometry, stating that
patients' medical histories belong to optometrists, not
retailers such as Reynolds.
Justice, even when long delayed, is always sweet, and this
week Catherine Stauffer is relishing it.
In October 1991, during the heat of the battle over Ballot
Measure 9, Stauffer was covering the premiere of an anti-gay
video at the Foursquare Church in Southeast Portland for
Just Out newspaper. She was spotted by Scott Lively,
the burly mouthpiece of the Oregon Citizens Alliance. He
wasn't exactly glad to see her.
"He picked me up, threw me into a wall and dragged me out
into the street," says Stauffer.
In 1992, she sued Lively and the OCA over the incident
and won a $20,000 settlement from Lively and another $10,000
from the OCA.
But until last week, Stauffer didn't see a penny.
Lively, an activist-turned-writer (in 1995 he self-published
a book comparing gays with Nazis), recently got a law degree
from a Southern California Christian school. Lively could
not be reached for comment, but according to correspondence
Stauffer received from him, he plans to do pro bono work
as a Christian missionary.
Problem is, you can't join the California Bar with outstanding
judgments. Before he can practice law, Lively has to pay
up, and last week Stauffer received a first installment
of $10,000.
As for the OCA's payment, Stauffer is still waiting. The
group is circulating another anti-gay initiative this year,
and she's watching it closely.
"I still have $10,000 due from the OCA, and I intend to
get it," says Stauffer, who is now a fine-arts photographer.
"If they gear up with a big campaign, I'm going to go after
their money."
--Patty Wentz
|