
Seen
a Rogue on the loose?
Get in touch with our Roguemeister:
JOHN SCHRAG
jschrag@wweek.com
(503) 243-2122
FAX:
(503) 243-1115
Everything is not coming up roses at the Rosie awards.
The annual advertising love-fest on Friday at the downtown
Marriott is not going to be a full house. The agency Elvis
& Bonaparte is boycotting the awards, claiming that
the Portland Advertising Federation is censoring
its work.
Elvis & Bonaparte, a $15 million downtown Portland
agency, was invited to submit a "bumper" to the show. These
two- to three-minute films provide agencies with a showcase
for their work, giving them a chance to let creative juices
flow without having to kowtow to a client. The problem,
according to PAF, which organizes the Rosies, is that Elvis
& Bonaparte let themselves flow just a little too freely.
The E&B movie, "Reach and Frequency," parodies a trailer
for a 1970s porn movie set in an advertising agency called
Tucker, Swallow and Rockhard. As might be expected, the
spoof is sexually suggestive, and there is some male nudity.
After viewing the movie, Lori Miller, executive director
of the PAF, determined it wasn't suitable for the Rosie
audience. For the first time in the Rosie's 40-year history,
a bumper was pulled from the program.
Elvis & Bonaparte is calling it censorship, charging
that the PAF, of all organizations, should not be stifling
creativity. We think it's fine for PAF to exercise discretion
in what it shows to its 800-member organization. What is
roguish is that PAF, which has no guidelines for bumpers,
let things go this far without checking in with the agency.
E&B Creative Director David Helfrey at says sex, drugs
and violence have been shown in past bumpers and he had
no reason to think his movie wouldn't be accepted.
Tim Findlay, who produces the award show for PAF, says
he tried to reach the agency to go over the concept, but
he concedes he should have tried harder. We agree. If the
PAF was changing the rules this year, everyone should have
known in advance.
Note: For those who aren't afraid of of sex and bad
clothing, the video will soon be available at www.reachfrequency.com.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Willamette Week | originally
published November 23,
1999
|