Portland Economist: New ODOT Audit "Worse than Useless"

Transportation agency's competence in question as Brown, lawamkers seek big funding package.

Oregon highway (Pixabay)

There's one thing on which Gov. Kate Brown and legislative leaders in both parties agree—they all badly want to pass a transportation-funding package in the 2017 legislative session that opened today.

"Our economy and the safety of our communities cannot wait," Brown said in a statement of her agenda last month.

But Joe Cortright, a Portland economist who's been a longtime critic of the Oregon Department of Transportation, says a new audit of the agency timed to give lawmakers confidence in its operations is "worse than useless."

In an op-ed piece he penned today for the website Bike Portland, Cortright says a $1 million audit, first reported by the Portland Tribune, failed in numerous ways.

In particular, Cortright says, the audit produced by McKinsey & Co. purports to assess whether ODOT can complete projects on time and on budget—but omits the agency's biggest screw-ups from its analysis.

"This would be rather like the White Star Line reporting the on-time arrivals of its ships traveling between London and New York with a footnote saying "This data doesn't include the indefinitely delayed arrival of RMS Titanic," Cortright writes.

ODOT's effectiveness is important because the agency would be responsible for spending the $400 to $500 million or more lawmakers and Brown hope raise this session.

The Oregon Transportation Commission will meet on Feb. 2 at 10 am for a special meeting to review the audit.

Willamette Week’s reporting has concrete impacts that change laws, force action from civic leaders, and drive compromised politicians from public office. Support WW's journalism today.