The only glimpse most people have ever had of In Other
Words, the Northeast Portland feminist bookstore, is through the
ruthless parody featured on the IFC television series
Portlandia.
In one episode, the
store’s two female employees—with their curtains of hair, baggy linen
clothes and deadly patronizing tone—debate whether or not to stock a
book on modern feminism.
“That’s a top-selling author,” one says. “Do we want that in here?”
“No,” the other responds. “We want a bottom-selling author.”
Parody is often a
barbed compliment. For Johanna Brenner, co-founder of In Others Words,
where the scenes were filmed, the depiction of an insular feminist
bookstore alienating customers and neglecting financial opportunities is
comic and a sharp insider’s view of feminism.
And the truth in the satire may be helping kill the 18-year-old bookstore.
In Other Words is
sliding toward financial collapse. The Women’s Community Education
Project, which runs the bookstore, ran $18,743 in the red last year.
This month, the store laid off its only two employees. Annual sales are
down 73 percent from where they were four years ago.
The number of
feminist bookstores nationwide has dropped to nine. In Other Words’
board members acknowledge the store may be headed for closure—and the
next-closest bookstore dedicated solely to women’s issues is in Austin,
Texas.
Brenner says that
would be the city’s loss. “There are still a lot of people in Portland
who really appreciate the need to have a space that’s explicitly
feminist,” she says.
Last
summer, In Other Words tried to expand its appeal by calling itself a
“resource center.” As the store’s website puts it, “We are a feminist
community center and our mission is to support, enrich, and empower the
feminist community through literature, art, and educational and cultural
events.”
But In Other Words also struggles because it’s lost its relevance to a new generation of women—a reality that suggests feminist bookstores are simply out of date. “People
don’t see it as urgent anymore, because feminist issues have been
mainlined into many different areas,” says Bren Murphy, associate
professor of communications and gender studies at Loyola University
Chicago.
It’s
obviosly tough for retail businesses. Katie Carter, who was laid off as
In Other Words’ program director, says the store faces the same
economic pressures as retail bookstores everywhere. “Independent
bookstores are dropping like flies, and it’s not particular to feminist
bookstores,” Carter says.
But many of the problems at In Other Words are of its own making.
For
years, a single source of income helped prop up the store’s finances: an
exclusive contract to sell textbooks on women’s studies to Portland
State University students. The store’s tax returns (which are a public
record because it’s owned by a nonprofit) show that nearly half of In
Other Words’ revenues came from such sales last year. But a 2008 federal
law effectively ended the practice of holding students captive to where
they can buy their textbooks.
Even though In Other
Words saw this coming—the law didn’t take effect until last summer—the
board that runs the store wasn’t prepared for the change. A statement
from the board says the store faces an “unforeseen immediate financial
crisis.”
The nonprofit running
the store has turned to donors in the past to pay the bills and has
counted on volunteers to stand by the business.
This
time is different. Volunteers say the board sprang a new business plan
on supporters this month that included laying off the staff.
Since its inception, In Other Words has depended almost exclusively on dozens of volunteers to run events and staff the store.
Yet according to Ali
Kafka, who’s been a volunteer at the bookstore for the past eight
months, they were kept in the dark about key decisions.
“We’re here day to
day. You guys aren’t,” Kafka said at a tense board meeting last week.
“We are the only feminist community center in Portland, and right now it
feels like [the board is] perpetuating oppression, labor exploitation,
and hypocrisy.”
Many
volunteers say their loyalty is now in doubt. Kate Shrum, a four-year
volunteer at In Other Words, holds the new business plan that called for
the layoffs and points to the graph that shows the business still
losing money well into next year: “If this is what feminism looks like
in Portland, thenmaybe we shouldn’t be doing this,” she says.
Brenner does not
share that sentiment. She helped start In Other Words in 1993, raising
$60,000 from like-minded community members. She also loaned the store
$35,000, which has been on the books for years and hasn’t been paid
back.
Brenner, who retired from the board last month, still believes in the power of Portland’s feminist community. “We’re still performing a very important educational and political function,” she says. “I’m hopeful. People just need to get their butts over to Killingsworth and support us.”
Susan Post, owner of BookWoman in Austin, says feminist bookstores also must work harder to remain relevant.
“There hasn’t been a
burning desire to change the world,” Post says. “People still want to
save the whales and have clean water, but women’s rights are on the back
burner.”
can we stop already with the feminist lies! the only thing the feminist movement did was make women work harder than they already were: working full time, working at home, having the kids, being a great bed partner...it's exhausting. we got more and more heaped upon us...where's the great freedom in this? our children are on drugs, dropping out of high school, pregnant, and we got some kind of "freedom"?
I would like to purchase a gift certificate at In Other Words and leave it for the commenter, "I will because" to purchase a book that will hopefully empower her to see beyond her myopic vision of feminism...and maybe happen upon a reading of Dirty Queer? Is this possible?
Yes, it is exhausting, but at least we can own property, vote and control our own reproduction. We can own businesses, become lawyers, politicians and doctors. We can leave abusive situations, get a divorce and go to college wherever we want to. Your daughter can play sports in school thanks to Title 9. You can thank the women's movement that your father or husband doesn't have to sign before you can start a business, get a bank account, a loan or buy property,
Sounds to me like "iwillbecause" still lives in that realm of oppression. I feel quite sorry for you. Fortunately we now live in a world where you can chose to say no to some of those things...don't want to work full time? don't want to be a great bed partner all the time? Don't want to have kids? THEN DON'T. And then be thankful that you live in a time in which you have the choice to say no.
Looking at the caption, I see they have a "Board Chairman," who is female. Was that misreported? If not, that ironically doesn't seem very feminist. I thought we were now supposed to use either the gender-specific term "Chairwoman" or the gender-neutral "Chair." I must not have the latest PC dictionary and style guide; maybe I should go buy one at the bookstore before it goes out of business . . .
When I moved to Portland 13 years ago I found my community in the aisles of In OtherWords listening to Inga Muscio reading from her (then) new book, "Cunt". I have continued to join my community at In Other Words to hear my friends sing, share stories they have written, and watch wonderful films directed by women.
I have also, over the last 13 years watched In Other Words begin to show signs of ware. At times, it literally feels dusty and several times I have sat on chairs I would not see fit to donate to goodwill. Obviously, this signals financial problems but also perpetuates financial problems.
I would suggest coalition building and using In Other Words as a hub for feminist activity in the community. Bitch magazine moved to town 4 years ago and has struggled financially. Siren Nation Women's Music Festival was born 5 years ago (under In Other Words Non Profit umbrella). Rock and Roll Camp for Girls is thriving and relevant.
In Other Words can be a pillar, a leader in the thriving feminist community in Portland. Feminism is highly relevant in Portland. A hub, a resource center/book store/coffee shop/safe space/hang out/hook up/meet up is highly desirable. Frankly, I want my city to be relevant nationally as a leader in feminism.
I believe this can be done and In Other Words can be the mothership. To keep it alive as it once was intended is obviously not fiscally sound. Re-imaging the intention of the space, building coalitions , and involving the community in a way that inspires their loyalty might work.
I for one would be willing to donate some chairs and a couch or two. The article failed to mention all the awesome, quirky, fun events that go on at In Other Words. It's not all linen and satire. There is real good stuff that happens there. Let us not think like linear capitalists. Money does not equal worth or relevance. But, money is needed to keep the place in a position to be relevant.
In Other Words was a fantastic idea that has been constantly plagued by bad management. i could tell you stories. But I won't because i'm so tired of talking about this store whose staff/volunteers and board are from different planets, which puts sole trust in one manager who is never questioned and which has never once had a solid financial plan. I'm pretty sure feminism ushered in our right to go to business school, but no one associated with this store ever found that important.
It's not that the store isn't successful because it is irrelevant or because we don't "need" it. Do we need half the small retail stories that exists in Portland? No, but they offer cool and/or interesting stuff to buy in strategic locations.
"but at least we can own property, vote and control our own reproduction. We can own businesses, become lawyers, politicians and doctors."
Women have had the legal right to do and be all of those in America for over a century--and women have owned property in the US since the Revolutionary war.
"We can leave abusive situations, get a divorce and go to college wherever we want to."
Women have been doing all of those for the past 250 years in America. Historical records of woman-initiated divorce are easy to find, and date back to the 1700s. Most colleges have admitted women for over 125 years, and two women's colleges have existed for longer than that.
"Your daughter can play sports in school thanks to Title 9."
No, your daughter can *play school sponsored sports" thanks for Title 9 forcing money be paid to fund it.
"You can thank the women's movement that your father or husband doesn't have to sign before you can start a business, get a bank account, a loan or buy property"
Again, women have started businesses, gotten loan and accounts, and bought property in the US for over 150 years, and in some cases far longer than that.
And in other countries, these rights have been enjoyed by women far longer than in America--and it had nothing to do with a "women's movement". In some countries, women have had them since the start of the first millenium. Even Islam (no, not fundamentalist) provides rights of property, divorce, higher education, money, and other similar rights--and has for over 1200 years.
Americans think everything starts and ends here, don't they? And the inevitable humorless responses will prove it.